A few days ago this particular book was brought to my attention. In the interest of being completely honest, I have not read this book. I have read the synopsis of the book and I have heard it detailed by others within the Ds community whose opinions I respect highly.
In the interest of trying to teach two of her older children about the diagnosis of their new sibling, whom has Down syndrome, this mother described him as being almost Peter Pan in his nature. Here it the "about the author" taken directly from Amazon:
A wife and mother of three amazing children- Jada, Asher and Logan. When planning for children, you think of the perfect world. You start to dream and imagine what they will look like and what they will become. From the color of their eyes and hair, to their personalities... you imagine perfection. When our third child was born, what we had imagined as perfect was a little altered. When given the news that our son had Down Syndrome, we were filled with so many questions and concerns. It didn't take long for us to realize that he was a perfect gift that God had entrusted to us. Through it all, we wouldn't change a thing. Our kids asked what Down Syndrome was, we had a hard time figuring out the right verbiage. Then it hit me...Logan is like Peter Pan!! He never wanted to grow up, he was a lot of fun to be around, and people were drawn to him. That is our son Logan. Our kids understood that it wasn't a scary thing, and that other children would wish they would have a brother or sister with Down Syndrome too. I was inspired to write a children's book that would help other siblings, students and families feel comfortable knowing that although it may be a different road to travel, it's an amazing journey to be on. We thank God we have Peter Pan living in our house!
First of all; my daughter is NOT some "forever child" that is funny all the time. Yes, she brings great joy to all of our lives. Yes, she has an amazing personality that draws people to her. Yes, I happen to think she is the most beautiful creature to ever walk this earth, BUT she is not always happy. She is not always fun to be around. She isn't always in the mood for people to swoon over her. In other words...she is NORMAL.
It hurts me and saddens me that this woman has this view of our children. I have fought these last five years to overcome such ridiculous stereotypes and here I find myself having to fight someone within my own community.
To think that Emily longs to remain a child all her life astounds me. This girl is almost 5 going on 20. She loves being a "big girl" and will get quite angry at you when you try and treat her like a baby. When one of the kids talks to her in the "baby" voice, you can see her expression and just know she is thinking..."Seriously, I can understand you, please talk to me on my level."
Some advocates have reached out to the author of this book and been met with nothing but resistance. She fails to grasp why so many of us (and trust me, there are MANY) have a problem with this book. While I don't think she intended harm, if this material gets put into schools to help others learn of Down syndrome, we are headed for trouble.
I recall the moment we had to sit down and explain to our children that Emily had Down syndrome. I was terrified because I was unsure what to say and even more unsure how they would handle the news. I think you have all heard how it went...Me and Hubby sitting the kids down for our very "serious" discussion...Hubby saying (in the absence of how to say it better) Emily has Down syndrome. Both us looking at all the kids holding our breath's for the questions sure to come....Jake speaking up "Is she going to come home soon?"...our nodding our heads waiting for the "difficult" questions to come...Jake again responding "Oh, well okay then. What's for dinner?".
You see, our children love her because she is their sister. They didn't need a five hour presentation on the ins and outs of Ds. Over the years, questions have arisen and we sit down and take them as they come. Mostly it was about her heart surgery and how long she would be in the hospital. Caleb was just two when Emily was born. He is aware she has Ds, but in his mind, that is his sister and she gives good hugs and kisses.
Never have I heard any of the children refer to her as forever child like. Never have they questioned will she grow up. We all have hopes and dreams for her. She herself has desires, dreams, and hope for the future. At the ripe old age of 4 (almost 5 she would like me to remind you), she hasn't exactly mapped out her entire future, but she wants you to know she is going to have one and wants nothing more than to grow up, fall in love, and live the most amazing life anyone could imagine. (Sorry to tell her that no one will ever be good enough in my eyes, so she should forget that whole "fall in love" thing and just work on being a fiercely independent woman...

)
So, for the record...my daughter's name is Emily. She does not live in Never Never Land, but in beautiful San Diego. She has the desire to grow up and she will go on to be whatever she puts her mind to. She is amazing. She is beautiful. She is the center of my world. Oh, and she has Down syndrome.
No Peter Pan for us, thank you very much.